NYC Gun Appeals by @2Aupdates
Copy base
Report abuse
NY Supreme Court
NY Appellate Court
Gun Permit Bribery Cases
Views
grid
Grid view
team
1 hidden field
Filter
Group
Sort
Case
1
Garofalo v. NYC
2
Missry v. Caban
3
Spencer v. Sewell
4
Gindi v. Sewell
5
Coppolecchia v. Shea
6
Caraballoso v. Sewell
7
Potter v. Sewell
8
Edery v. Sewell
9
Campisi v. Sewell
10
Elishayev v. NYC
11
Sanicola v. NYC
12
Gindi v. Sewell
13
Spinelli v. NYC
14
Rodrigues v. NYC
15
Drenis v. Sewell
16
Johnson v. Shea
17
Charles v. Shea
18
Agro v. Shea
19
Rozenberg v. Shea
20
Leifer v. Shea
21
Cheng v. Shea
22
Popovic v. NYC
23
Cedano v. NYC
24
Feltman v. Shea
25
Qi v. Shea
26
Fata v. Shea
27
Vicari v. Shea
28
Klein v. NYC
29
Coppolecchia v. O'Neill
30
Zeron v. Shea
31
Cheng v. Shea
32
Rozenberg v. Shea
33
Morse v. Shea
34
Jaeger v. NYC
35
Callahan v. NYC
36
Thomas v. NYC
37
Drenis v. Shea
38
Yukanov v. NYC
39
Tzoulis v. NYPD
40
Sappe v. O'Neill
41
Campisi v. Shea
42
DiRusso v. Shea
43
Filani v. NYC
44
Huber v. O'Neill
45
Bolfo v. O'Neill
46
Mudrick v. NYC
47
Scobbo v. NYC
48
Daniarov v. NYPD
49
Leo v. NYC
50
Palushaj v. NYPD
51
Girandola v. Shea
52
Colletta v. NYC
53
Knight v. NYC
54
Mendez v. O'Neill
55
McKenzie v. NYC
56
Tzoulis v. NYPD
57
Tsoulos v. O'Neill
58
Deodato v. O'Neill
59
Tate v. O'Neill
60
Jones v. O'Neill
61
Rubin v NYPD
62
Schupak v. NYC
63
Thomas v. O'Neill
64
Allen v. O'Neill
65
Livingston v. O'Neill
66
Gopie v. O'Neill
67
Geyman v. NYC
68
Kaplan v. O'Neill
69
Gjelaj v. Bratton
70
Priester v. Bratton
71
Corbett v. NYC
72
Gomez v. Bratton
73
Delgado v. Kelly
74
Gonzalez v. NYPD
75
Gonzalez v. Kelly
76
Caputo v. Kelly
77
Tsang v. Kelly
78
Pilgrim v. NYPD
79
Lederman v. NYPD
80
Connolly v. NYPD
81
Erhunmwunse v. NYPD
82
Campbell v. Kelly
83
Friedman v. Kelly
84
Torres v. Prasso
85
Ahmed v. NYPD
86
Steinfelder v. Kelly
87
Funicello v. NYPD
88
Rucker v. NYPD
89
Donadio v. Kelly
90
Maldonado v. Kelly
91
Georgakis v. Kelly
92
Farrell v. Kelly
93
Ostrowski v. NYC
94
Koenig v. Kelly
95
Ricatto v. Kelly
96
Beach v. Kelly
97
Thomas v. NYPD
98
Churchill v. Kelly
99
Distefano v. Kelly
100
Fauntleroy v. Kelly
101
Acosta v. Kelly
102
Imberman v. Kelly
103
Dziemnian v. Kelly
104
Olivera v. Kelly
105
Timlin v. Kelly
106
Gonzalez v. Kelly
107
Brody v. NYC
108
Caceres v. Kelly
109
Papaioannou v. Kelly
110
Passarelli v. Kelly
111
E'Arrigo v. Kelly
112
Radic v. Prasso
113
Hinton v. NYC
114
D'Onofrio v. NYC
115
Geissman v. Kerik
116
Gregg v. Kerik
117
Muci v. Kerik
118
Pinilla v. Safir
119
Allone v. Safir
120
Turner v. Codd
121
Klapper v. Codd
122
Katz v. Murphy
Drag to adjust the number of frozen columns
Decision Date
85250/2022
Porzio
Bellantoni
Multiple
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Removed
January 3, 2024
160788/2023
Kelley
Woller
Handgun carry
N/A - Permit delays
Settlement
October 11, 2023
154530/2023
Kelley
Thomas
Handgun carry
N/A - Permit delays
Settlement
June 13, 2023
153084/2023
Moyne
Thomas
Handgun carry
N/A - Permit delays
Settlement
May 31, 2023
154522/2021
James
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
April 26, 2023
152846/2023
Kraus
Tersigni
Handgun carry
N/A - Permit delays
Settlement
April 24, 2023
150014/2023
Bannon
Randazzo
Handgun premises
N/A - Permit delays
Stipulation
March 13, 2023
161014/2022
Kelley
Randazzo
Handgun carry
N/A - Permit delays
Stipulation
February 21, 2023
150931/2023
Stroth
Randazzo
Handgun carry
N/A - Permit delays
Settlement
January 6, 2023
156587/2022
Bannon
Colihan
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Settlement
November 29, 2022
153446/2020
James
Adler
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Domestic incidents
Denied
October 27, 2022
158142/2022
Kotler
Randazzo
Handgun premises
N/A - Permit delays
Settlement
September 28, 2022
504915/2021
Velasquez
Pro se
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Settlement
September 6, 2022
159389/2021
Hagler
Geter
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Settlement
August 25, 2022
155692/2022
Frank
Randazzo
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Settlement
July 5, 2022
161281/2021
Hagler
Levine
Rifle/Shotgun
Arrests
Convictions
Domestic incidents
Denied
May 2, 2022
726017/2021
Caloras
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
March 11, 2022
151491/2021
Tisch
Randazzo
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
January 27, 2022
154520/2021
Saunders
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Discontinued
November 29, 2021
151168/2021
James
Pro se
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
October 12, 2021
154521/2021
Love
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
September 28, 2021
152202/2021
Engoron
Colihan
Handgun premises
Arrests
Driving record
Domestic incidents
Denied
July 2, 2021
157848/2020
Engoron
Colihan
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Settlement
June 17, 2021
160938/2020
Engoron
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
June 14, 2021
150615/2021
Edmead
Randazzo
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
June 14, 2021
155882/2020
Edmead
Randazzo
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
June 9, 2021
161001/2020
Rakower
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Remanded
May 28, 2021
150339/2021
Chan
Colihan
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
May 6, 2021
151928/2020
James
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
May 3, 2021
154821/2020
Engoron
Schechter
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
April 19, 2021
152437/2021
Kotler
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
March 19, 2021
29135/2020E
Taylor
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Transferred
March 3, 2021
157936/2020
Edmead
Brill
Rifle/Shotgun
Permit violation
Mental health
Denied
February 11, 2021
155406/2020
Rakower
Colihan
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Remanded
February 4, 2021
151160/2020
Crane
Adler
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
February 3, 2021
161577/2019
Kotler
Adler
Multiple
Domestic incidents
Permit violation
Transferred
January 19, 2021
154770/2020
Engoron
Randazzo
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
January 4, 2021
152097/2020
Edmead
Colihan
Handgun premises
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Denied
December 29, 2020
153919/2020
Edmead
Stapleton
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
December 24, 2020
151336/2020
Engoron
Grunwald
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Arrests
Driving record
Denied
December 8, 2020
153703/2020
Edmead
Randazzo
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
December 8, 2020
154080/2020
Rakower
Randazzo
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Settlement
December 7, 2020
159335/2019
James
Van-Lare
Handgun premises
Domestic incidents
Denied
November 1, 2020
161603/2019
Crane
Abrams
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
August 18, 2020
157451/2019
Crane
Baumgarten
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
August 10, 2020
155756/2019
Edmead
Baumgarten
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
July 8, 2020
150802/2020
Engoron
Colihan
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Granted
July 8, 2020
156880/2019
Kotler
Rubin
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
June 12, 2020
162287/2019
Rakower
Adler
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
May 7, 2020
150896/2020
Edmead
Barnaby
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Settlement
May 3, 2020
161856/2019
Crane
Schechter
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
April 28, 2020
158219/2019
Kotler
Baumgarten
Rifle/Shotgun
Domestic incidents
Denied
December 16, 2019
101449/2019
Kotler
Pro se
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
December 12, 2019
154736/2019
Kotler
Schechter
Handgun carry
Arrests
Convictions
Denied
November 20, 2019
159003/2019
Engoron
Colihan
Rifle/Shotgun
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Denied
October 3, 2019
154647/2019
Rakower
Stapleton
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Stipulation
October 2, 2019
154933/2019
Crane
Baumgarten
Handgun carry
Arrests
Driving record
Settlement
September 25, 2019
156102/2019
Kotler
Baumgarten
Rifle/Shotgun
Arrests
Failure to disclose
Settlement
September 24, 2019
151123/2019
Kotler
Bellantoni
Handgun carry
Arrests
Driving record
Denied
August 22, 2019
157286/2018
Kotler
Thomas
Handgun carry
Arrests
Convictions
Denied
July 8, 2019
152027/2019
Kotler
Stapleton
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Stipulation
May 16, 2019
159536/2018
Perry
Baumgarten
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
April 9, 2019
151785/2018
Crane
Tilem
Handgun carry
Domestic incidents
Failure to disclose
Permit violation
Denied
January 17, 2019
152341/2018
Engoron
Tilem
Handgun premises
Arrests
Convictions
Denied
August 30, 2018
157351/2017
Kelley
Baumgarten
Multiple
Domestic incidents
Failure to disclose
Denied
August 15, 2018
153736/2017
Jaffe
Feerick-Kossmann
Handgun premises
Arrests
Failure to disclose
Denied
July 12, 2018
154474/2018
Crane
Baumgarten
Handgun premises
Arrests
Driving record
Failure to disclose
Settlement
May 1, 2018
159562/2016
Engoron
Glen
Handgun premises
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Permit violation
Denied
April 19, 2017
157443/2016
Lobis
Santangelo
Handgun carry
Arrests
Convictions
Driving record
Denied
March 14, 2017
153936/2016
Billings
Schechter
Handgun premises
Arrests
Convictions
Discontinued
February 6, 2017
158273/2016
Edmead
Pro se
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
June 12, 2015
101428/2014
Wooten
Handgun carry
Arrests
Domestic incidents
False statements
Denied
https://cases.justia.com/new-york/other-courts/2015-2015-ny-slip-op-31097-u.pdf
October 11, 2013
104061/2012
Ling-Cohan
Handgun premises
Arrests
Domestic incidents
False statements
Denied
https://law.justia.com/cases/new-york/other-courts/2013/2013-ny-slip-op-51656-u.html
September 13, 2013
100390/2013
Chan
Handgun premises
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Failure to disclose
Denied
February 26, 2013
103984/2012
Kern
Handgun premises
Arrests
Convictions
Failure to disclose
Denied
https://cases.justia.com/new-york/other-courts/2013-ny-slip-op-30435-u.pdf
January 11, 2013
113232/2010
Schlesinger
Handgun premises
Convictions
Denied
May 14, 2012
112392/2011
Wooten
Handgun carry
Lack of character
Denied
https://casetext.com/case/tsang-v-kelly
October 18, 2011
401766/2011
Stallman
Handgun premises
Arrests
Failure to disclose
Denied
March 31, 2011
112434/2010
Gische
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
June 11, 2010
100138/2010
Sherwood
Handgun premises
Arrests
Failure to disclose
Denied
https://casetext.com/case/in-re-connolly-v-ny-pd-license-div
May 24, 2010
114754/2009
Diamond
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
May 5, 2010
117015/2009
Solomon
Handgun premises
Arrests
Permit violation
Failure to disclose
Denied
October 16, 2009
110367/2007
Madden
Handgun premises
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Denied
https://cases.justia.com/new-york/other-courts/2009-ny-slip-op-33326-u.pdf
July 29, 2009
105476/2009
Edmead
Handgun premises
Failure to renew
Denied
https://casetext.com/case/in-matter-of-torres-v-prasso
July 13, 2009
104077/2009
Lehner
Handgun premises
Arrests
Failure to disclose
Denied
June 24, 2009
101715/2009
Tolub
Multiple
Arrests
Convictions
Permit violation
Denied
June 16, 2009
100059/2009
Goodman
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
https://www.leagle.com/decision/innyco20090701360
June 10, 2009
103531/2009
Lehner
Handgun premises
Domestic incidents
Denied
July 31, 2008
104129/2008
Stone
Handgun premises
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Permit violation
Denied
April 18, 2008
113136/2007
Payne
Handgun carry
Permit violation
Denied
April 16, 2008
111962/2007
Cahn
Handgun premises
Arrests
Driving record
Denied
https://casetext.com/case/matter-of-georgakis-v-kelly
October 16, 2007
106021/2007
Payne
Handgun carry
Arrests
Granted
https://casetext.com/case/matter-of-farrell-v-kelly
October 3, 2007
108388/2007
Edmead
Multiple
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Permit violation
Denied
September 4, 2007
103424/2007
Solomon
Multiple
Permit violation
Granted
https://casetext.com/case/in-matter-of-koenig-v-kelly
June 26, 2007
103054/2007
Edmead
Handgun carry
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Failure to disclose
Denied
May 18, 2007
113372/2006
Solomon
Handgun premises
Permit violation
Granted
December 21, 2006
401922/2006
Cahn
Multiple
Permit violation
Denied
October 17, 2006
106196/2006
Tejada
Handgun carry
False statements
Denied
September 18, 2006
80428/2005
Gigante
Handgun premises
Failure to renew
Granted
August 18, 2006
105213/2004
Cahn
Handgun premises
Permit violation
Remanded
July 6, 2006
105023/2006
Wetzel
Rifle/Shotgun
Arrests
Granted
August 29, 2005
107255/2005
Stone
Multiple
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Permit violation
Denied
July 29, 2005
104199/2005
Stone
Rifle/Shotgun
Arrests
Domestic incidents
Permit violation
Denied
August 13, 2004
107144/2004
Lippmann
Handgun carry
Convictions
Granted
May 7, 2004
117474/2002
Heitler
Handgun carry
No proper cause
Denied
March 29, 2004
119772/2003
Tejada
Handgun premises
Unknown
Granted
October 30, 2003
111535/2003
Soto
Handgun carry
Domestic incidents
Permit violation
Denied
September 30, 2003
108951/2003
Soto
Handgun carry
Arrests
Remanded
July 14, 2003
126191/2002
Stone
Handgun premises
Arrests
Convictions
Permit violation
Granted
March 27, 2003
122528/2002
Stone
Handgun carry
Arrests
Convictions
Denied
February 3, 2003
122529/2002
Zweibel
Handgun carry
Failure to renew
Denied
January 10, 2003
110699/2002
Tolub
Rifle/Shotgun
Arrests
Denied
July 2, 2002
100678/2002
Allen
Handgun carry
Lack of character
Denied
May 24, 2002
115716/2001
Shulman
Handgun carry
Arrests
Remanded
October 24, 2001
112098/2001
Lehner
Handgun premises
Failure to renew
Denied
August 8, 2001
124759/2000
DeGrasse
Handgun premises
Permit violation
Denied
July 6, 2001
124560/2000
Friedman
Rifle/Shotgun
Arrests
Failure to disclose
Denied
May 21, 2001
111280/1999
Gans
Handgun premises
Arrests
False statements
Remanded
March 21, 2001
114744/1999
Weissberg
Handgun premises
Range attendance
Remanded
December 12, 1975
85 Misc. 2d 483
Helman
Handgun premises
No proper cause
Remanded
https://casetext.com/case/turner-v-codd
May 14, 1974
78 Misc. 2d 377
Markowitz
Handgun premises
Unstable employment
Remanded
https://casetext.com/case/klapper-v-codd
January 20, 1972
71 Misc. 2d 220
Davidson
Handgun premises
Arrests
Granted
https://casetext.com/case/katz-v-murphy
Find a view
Grid view
Kanban
Alert
Lorem ipsum
Okay
Press space bar to start a drag. When dragging you can use the arrow keys to move the item around and escape to cancel. Some screen readers may require you to be in focus mode or to use your pass through key