Author

Scorer: Last name, First initial

Title

Clarity of objectives

Appropriateness of methods

Outcome(s)

Data analysis

Generalizability: The ability to be applicable and reproducible

Relevance/Importance

Innovation: Reviewers prioritize topics of major importance to large numbers of emergency medicine researchers or clinicians

Quality of writing: Does this article reflect high quality writing and attention to detail?

Strength of conclusion(s)

Score

Please comment on "0=N/A Scores" and any other thoughts: